Sadie Plum, Luke Hayden, and Jessica Gutweiler


Amanda Gutweiler Hypes (later Kelley) left her three homeschooled children, Sadie, 10, Luke, 6, and Jessica, 3, home alone while she ran an errand. When she returned, the three had perished in a house fire. Kelley was originally accused of arson and was convicted in 2002 of three counts of first-degree murder. However, this conviction was thrown out in 2006 and the case was returned to court. In 2010 Kelley plead guilty to three counts of negligent homicide.

Date: January 9, 2001
Location: Tioga, Louisiana

Documents: Date:
Guilty in Fire Deaths of 3 Kids 2010-03-07